Let’s dive in!

Real connection is built when you can disagree and still stay close. When your tween can respectfully disagree with you, fully confident that your love is not conditional on them fitting into a specific mold.

It does mean you need to be confident in your own beliefs. But also, that you’re willing to listen to their emerging opinions.

So how does that work in the middle school years when they aren’t sure what their opinions are? When they’re impressionable? When their opinions change faster than the spring weather in Alberta, Canada — four different seasons in the span of a few hours.

When my daughters were in middle school there were three things I did to try to give them space to develop opinions but also give guidance so they didn’t go completely off the rails.

1. I created a mantra for myself so when they said something outlandish, as tweens do, I said to myself this isn’t their final answer. As long as it wasn’t illegal, immoral, or unethical I tried my best to stick to the five-to-one ratio where they talk 5 minutes to every minute that I talked. There was a lot of clock watching and tongue biting on my end and I didn’t always succeed — let’s keep it real!

However what I found was that they often just needed a safe place to air an idea, to talk it out. They needed someone who would listen without lecturing, someone who wouldn’t interrupt or try to change their mind, because they needed to talk it out to come to the conclusion on their own. If you’re like me, you know that sometimes it’s easier to get it out with someone sitting there so it doesn’t feel like you’re going crazy talking to yourself out loud.

Listening is step one. But how you react while you’re listening? That’s step two.

2. Regulate your reactions — all of them. This one took some deliberate practice, but learning to keep shock, surprise, horror, and even excitement off my face and to keep my body language neutral was key. Tweens are hypersensitive — they’re trying to individuate.

They want your approval but they also need a safe place to work through the things they’re thinking.

The goal is to regulate your emotions and stay neutral in reacting to what they’re saying. Try to match their energy level and tone.

For example, if they’re being chill and you’re elated that they finally figured something out and you go over the top, they’ll likely shut down. Or if they say something logical and you gush emotionally, there’s a communication mismatch. If they’re on the verge of tears and you speak logic to them, they’ll feel like you don’t get them.

So keep your response to anything shocking off your face and keep things regulated. Meet logic with logic. Emotion with emotion.

3. The third thing I did was teach them to think — really think. Our world is so divided because we’ve forgotten how to have dialogue, forgotten that a difference of opinion doesn’t have to mean the end of a relationship. Bringing critical thinking and arguing into your middle school homeschool will pay off.

I remember the incredulous looks on my daughters’ faces when I told them they could argue as much as they wanted. But fighting was not allowed.

An argument has a point, a claim, that has to be supported with research and examples. This forces deeper thinking and promotes looking at a topic from multiple sides. It pushes you to deliberately see if there’s any truth to the opposing view so you can squash objections — and in doing so both sides end up with a fresh perspective.

Even if they still hold firm to their original positions they now actually have a reason for their belief. Because they’re developing critical thinking skills, over time their stance may change as they gather new information and experiences. And that’s okay.

Fighting on the other hand is when it gets personal. Attacking someone’s character — the political mudslinging — that’s fighting. As soon as an argument crosses that line it’s no longer emotionally safe, thus the no fighting rule.

To this day, my daughters enjoy argument. It sharpens the mind, it forces them to think through difficult situations, to really put ideas to the test. And because of that they’re all strong confident young women.

Not argumentative, belligerent, or arrogant — that’s different. They don’t walk around thinking they’re always right and can prove it. They just don’t shy away from conflict because they know what they believe and can stand up for themselves as needed.

And when you can have a discussion with your kid — when you can disagree on an issue, not a parenting issue but an opinion — you build real connection. And that’s priceless.

Leave a comment

Let’s dive in…

Connection: The best friend trap

If you’ve found yourself trying to be your middle schooler’s best friend (instead of their parent), it’s not because you’re a pushover. You’re probably doing it because somewhere along the way you started to wonder — if I push back, will they push away? And that fear is real. Nobody wants to be the mom whose kid stops talking to her.

But your middle schooler doesn’t need you to be their best friend. What they need is a safe harbor.

Their brain isn’t fully developed yet. They need you to be the voice of reason — not someone who gets swept up in their whims right along with them. The hard calls are yours to make. And you can’t make them well if you’re worried about whether they like you in the moment. You have something they don’t yet have: the perspective of years. And that’s not a small thing. So use it.

It doesn’t mean you have to be an overprotective killjoy. You can absolutely be a yes-parent. You just also get to say no, when it matters.

One of the most helpful tools I know is the pre-made decision. It’s one I used a lot with my girls. I found that when we decided in advance how we were going to handle certain situations, it took the pressure off the moment. I didn’t have to think on my feet while everyone’s emotions were running high — including mine. The decision was already made. I just had to hold the line.

Try this one thing this week:

Think of a situation that — without fail — causes tension between you and your middle schooler. You already know what it is.

Talk it through together when you’re not in the middle of a crisis — when you’re both thinking rationally, emotions calm. Get on the same page about expectations and consequences ahead of time. When they’ve been part of working it through, your middle schooler feels heard.

And when the situation comes up, you both already know the outcome. It doesn’t mean there won’t be any emotional drama. But there will be less. Because you can stay level-headed, and that helps them regulate too.

Write it down. And when the moment comes — you’re not scrambling. You already know what you’re doing.

Subscribe now

Character: The foundation nobody sees

Character isn’t a box to check. It’s a construction project — one that takes years to build, and one you’re helping them start right now.

If you’ve ever heard that rhythmic pounding near a big construction site — that’s pile drivers, driving steel pilings deep into the ground before a single floor gets framed. But even before anything is done on site, someone has spent serious time figuring out exactly what kind of foundation is needed to support what’s coming. That work is invisible once the building is finished. But everything depends on it.

That’s what you’re doing with your middle schooler right now. You’re working on the foundation.

And just like in construction, it doesn’t happen all at once. Different trades come in at different stages, each one doing something different — but all working toward the same structure. With your middle schooler, it’s the same idea. Different circumstances, different seasons, different challenges — all of them opportunities for growth, all of them contributing to the same person being built.

Most people are so focused on what high school looks like that they rush right through this season. But middle school isn’t the warm-up. It’s the foundation. And if you feel like you’ve been rushing — you’re not too late. High school is when that foundation gets stress-tested. Which means right now, wherever you are in these middle school years, is still the right time to be intentional. The character qualities you help your kid build today are what they’ll lean on when high school gets hard.

Try this one thing this week:

If you’re wondering where to start, start with perseverance. A kid who believes they can figure things out — even when it’s hard — is set up for everything else. And it starts with how your middle schooler talks to themselves about hard things.

When they hit a wall with their schoolwork, the goal isn’t to convince them it’s easy. It’s to help them shift from I can’t do this to I can’t do this yet — I just haven’t figured out how. That’s a growth mindset. And it’s something you can practice this week.

The next time they get frustrated, sit with them in it for a moment. Then ask: what would help you understand this better?

Competence: The reset your tween’s schedule probably needs

Every learner has gaps. Every single one. You’re working through math and your middle schooler is asking you about a basic concept you covered last year — and suddenly you realize they can’t move forward because that piece never actually landed. That’s a gap. And it’s not a crisis. It’s just information.

The bigger worry most homeschool moms carry is this: what if I miss something? What if I can’t teach them everything they need? I carried that too — and for a while my answer was to try to do it all, all the time. Every subject, every day, every term. What I didn’t realize was that I was creating a different problem. Eight context switches a day. Nobody going deep on anything. My girls learning a little of everything and not much of anything well.

It wasn’t until I stepped back that I came up with what eventually became the Middle School On Track System. Fewer subjects, intentionally selected, completed within 12 weeks. Focused time and attention without the constant switching. My daughters tell me it’s what they wish I’d figured out sooner — because it actually worked.

You can’t do everything. So the goal isn’t to cover more ground — it’s to choose better.

Try this one thing this week:

Add up everything you’re currently asking your middle schooler to do academically in a week. Then look at the actual available time — take off sleep, meals, family activities, outside commitments. What’s left? Does your middle schooler realistically have enough time to do what’s on their plate — and do it well?

If the academic time commitment is more than their actual time, it’s time for a reset. Have a conversation with your tween and choose 1 hard, 1 medium, 1 fun, 1 easy subject to focus on for the next 6 weeks — then reassess.

Let’s dive in…

Connection

The kid you used to know is still in there

You used to know everything about them. What made them laugh, what scared them, the exact play-by-play of their day at co-op. And now? You get grunts. Closed doors. One-word answers when you’re lucky.

If you’re wondering whether something’s wrong with your middle schooler — or with you — take a breath. This is one of those seasons where what feels like a red flag is actually right on schedule.

Silence is a normal developmental stage — not necessarily a red flag. You want to look for distress under disrespect. They stop talking to you as much? That’s part of them trying to individuate. If they stop talking to everyone, completely withdraw, and spend all their time alone — then it’s time to pay closer attention.

But instead of getting your feelings hurt, try to remember what’s actually going on here. Resist the urge to lecture. Start talking to them like an adult — like you value their opinions. That doesn’t mean you need to do everything they want — just like you wouldn’t go along with every idea an adult friend shared with you. And yes, you’re still the parent.

So how do you connect with your non-communicative middle schooler?

• Pre-plan not to lecture

• Get your feelings under control — this isn’t about you

• Quit trying to be their friend — you’re their parent. Friendship with your kids comes later, once they’re adults. Right now, in middle school, they need you to be the grown-up, even as they push you away

• Be available

Try this week: Decide ahead of time what you’ll say when your middle schooler’s silence starts making you frustrated or hurt. Instead of a lecture, ask if you can give them a hug — sometimes they’ll say yes. If they say no, let it be. Or if they’re bracing for a lecture, offer kindness instead. Something like “Hey, I noticed you did X — thank you” or “I’m throwing a load of jeans in the washer — do you have any that need washing?”

They need you more than ever right now. Stay available. Give them the space to individuate.

Subscribe now

Character

Before you ground them for a month, read this

When your middle schooler lies to you, the instinct is to go straight to consequences. Ground them. Lecture them. Pull out the verses on honesty.

But what if the lie isn’t the real problem? What if it’s a symptom of something underneath — something worth getting curious about before you bring down the hammer?

Is lying a character issue — or a sign of something else?

I’m not saying lying is right. But I want to challenge you to look deeper and see why your middle schooler feels the need to lie in the first place. The Bible speaks a lot about lying, and there are real consequences to it. But before you ground them for a month, let’s get curious about the root.

Fear of disappointing you. Sometimes your disappointment is the worst form of punishment, and they’ll do anything to avoid it — so they evade the truth.

They’ll do just enough not to be technically lying. By the letter of the law, it’s done. By the spirit of the law, it’s not — because they half-heartedly finished something that isn’t really to standard. Even if it’s technically done, the quality is so poor it needs to be redone. The real issue? They’re overwhelmed by expectations.

They don’t want to feel stupid. So they say they understand when they don’t, hoping to magically figure it out after the fact. Maybe they’ve been asked something in front of their peers, and admitting ignorance would bring on ridicule or loss of respect. So they save face.

All three of these — fear of disappointing you, being overwhelmed by expectations, and saving face — come down to how you perceive them, how they perceive themselves, and how others perceive them. And when you get to the very root, it comes down to a lack of confidence in their true self.

Which is really about identity — something middle schoolers are wrestling with. This is the phase of life when they’re trying to figure out who they are, and they’re trying to uphold an identity while they explore. Maybe they’re working hard to hold up the identity of your responsible child, or the one who’s got it all together — until they don’t. And all of this comes down to safety in relationships.

So how are you responding to imperfections and challenges as your middle schooler builds confidence in their identity? How do you help build character without handing out a gold star for every little thing?

I grew up in a household that didn’t fight — everything got swept under the rug. When I discovered later that you could have a difference of opinion and still keep a relationship, it was life-changing.

I don’t know what it’s like in your household — or whether you’re inadvertently making it unsafe for your middle schooler to disagree, explore ideas, and fail at things. But let’s make honest discourse normal. Let’s not assume every hard moment is a character issue. Maybe what they need is some safe space to fail, try again, and develop character. It’s called developing for a reason — they don’t have it fully formed yet. They need a safe place to grow it.

That doesn’t mean we shrug and say lying is okay — knowing the reason doesn’t make it right. But we can have a real conversation about truth-telling, and then take it on ourselves to self-regulate: create a neutral face, and build trust by not overreacting when they tell us hard things.

Try this week: Pick one moment when your middle schooler tells you something hard — a mistake, a grade, something they did wrong — and practice the neutral face. No gasp, no lecture, no lightning-quick consequence. Just “thanks for telling me — let’s talk about it.” Watch what happens to their willingness to come to you next time.

Share Homeschooling Middle School

Competence

The weight-limit rule for a week of school

There’s a myth in a lot of homeschool circles: if the work is hard enough, the education must be good.

But I’ve watched rigor wear down smart, capable kids — mine included. And I’ve come to think about it differently now.

A rigorous curriculum doesn’t mean a rigorous education. Engagement beats rigor every time — until it doesn’t.

A program with a slight stretch produces more learning — and less stress — than an ultra-rigorous one that feels like pressure all the time. Being stretched to the max, day after day, wears everyone down.

I’ll be honest — I’ve been pushing myself hard recently, and things have lost their joy. I was in learning mode for everything. I wasn’t even consciously competent — I joked that I was consciously incompetent.

You may have heard of the stages of competence —

Unconscious incompetence. Blissful ignorance. You don’t know what you don’t know.

Conscious incompetence. You realize there’s a gap in the skill, and either you do something about it or you live with it.

Conscious competence. You’re actively working on the skill. You’re a novice. You try, you fail, you learn, you try again. It’s a process.

Unconscious competence. A strong foundation. You’re confident in that area.

If you’ve got a rigorous course of study for your middle schooler, it’ll show the gaps quickly — and if those gaps are many and wide, it can be discouraging to see how much needs active work without some foundation of unconscious competence to stand on.

Sometimes you only realize the gap when the material is right in front of you. But something like the Progress Quick Check can help you see the areas for improvement ahead of time — so you can be selective with how you work through them. We chose a mix of levels so my girls would only be working in an area of barely-conscious competence in no more than two subjects at a time.

When your kid is struggling, it’s tempting to assume they just need to try harder — push through, stay positive, power up. But this has nothing to do with mindset. It’s capacity.

My husband would tell you the same thing about a job site. The trailer has a weight limit. Ignore it and you don’t get there faster — you blow a tire on the side of the road, and the whole job stops.

A week of school works the same way. If your kid has room for three hard things this week and two subjects are already stretching them — that’s the load. Adding a third doesn’t speed things up. It’s the blown tire. Stay inside the limit and you’ll actually get more done, because the work doesn’t get abandoned mid-week.

Try this week: Take an honest look at what you’re requiring of your middle schooler. How many of those things are genuinely hard for them right now? If it’s more than two, pick one to set down, simplify, or swap for something at their current level. Then watch what happens to their energy.

For a structured way to do this, pick up the Progress Quick Check — this resource walks you through seeing where your middle schooler actually is and helps you decide, with clarity, what to move forward with. Comment PROGRESS below and I’ll get it to you.

Leave a comment

Most connecting happens in the ordinary, everyday moments. Have you ever noticed that when your kid talks about a memory, it’s often something you completely forgot about? Connection happens in the liminal spaces — the transitions, the waiting times, the moments you feel unproductive, the white space in your calendar, the times you allow yourself to breathe and just be with your kids. Not when you’re busy trying to manufacture a memory or capture an Instagram-perfect moment.

Try this week — Protect one pocket of white space. Don’t fill it. Don’t plan it. Just be in the same room as your tween and see what happens.

Character

When kids are little, we need them to be obedient for their safety and well-being. They haven’t developed reasoning skills yet, and they’re dependent on us to help them make good choices. But as we move into the middle school years, it becomes less about blind obedience and more about dialogue and decision-making. So many of our fights come from this exact conflict. Remember — going from obedience to discussion can sound like back talk. That’s often because they don’t yet know how to discuss things. They’re learning a new skill, and we’re their first practice partner.

Try this week — The next time your tween pushes back, pause before reacting. Ask yourself, Is this back talk, or is this a kid trying to learn how to have a conversation with me? Then invite the discussion instead of shutting it down.

Competence

My husband is in construction, and recently he was telling me about a huge new school they’re building. They’ve got a ton of scaffolding and bracing holding the walls up while everything gets secured. Once the walls are properly anchored, they remove the scaffolding and take off the braces — but not a moment before. Otherwise the wall would fall over and the whole project would be ruined. They’d have to start over.

That’s exactly what your middle schooler needs. They need their independence scaffolded. They need supports in place so they can confidently practice doing their work, and then over time, as they build their skills, you can remove the scaffolding and they’ll still be standing on their own.

Imagine putting up a wall without any supports. On a sunny, calm day it might look perfectly fine. But the second there’s any stress — any wind, any pressure — it’ll crumble. That’s the same as your child. Sometimes we think they’re strong and capable of handling things, and meanwhile they’re cracking on the inside from the stress of trying not to fail. Let’s take the pressure off and start scaffolding instead.

It looks different for different tasks. Essentially, you’re providing as much support as needed for them to confidently do the task — and once you see they can do it, you start backing away. Slowly.

It’s a little like Jenga. You’ve got that tall tower of blocks, and you keep removing pieces. Pull the wrong one and the whole thing crashes, and you have to rebuild from scratch. But if you remove the blocks strategically, the tower stays standing. As you strategically remove supports, your middle schooler builds competence. And here’s the difference from the game — when you remove a support from your child, confidence and competence grow in its place. So they stay standing.

Try this week — Pick one task your tween is currently struggling with and ask, Is there enough scaffolding here for them to succeed? Then pick one task they’ve already proven they can do, and remove a piece of scaffolding. Most kids don’t want us doing for them what they can already do for themselves.

Need Fresh Eyes on Your Homeschool?

Sometimes you’re too close to your own situation to see it clearly. That’s what a Fresh Eyes Call is for. In 20 minutes, we’ll talk through a situation you’re wrestling with, and you’ll leave with one small suggestion to bring a little calm back to your homeschool days.

I have 3 spots open this week. Book your Fresh Eyes Call → https://tidycal.com/marina4/fresh-eyes-call

The 3 Cs Your Middle Schooler Needs This Week

Every week, I break down one thing you can try in each of the three areas that matter most in middle school: Connection, Character, and Competence.

Some weeks you’ll read all three and think, yeah, we’re doing okay there. Other weeks one will hit you right in the chest. That’s the one to pay attention to.

Here’s this week’s dose.

Connection

Your tween pushing you away? That’s not the problem. Your reaction to it might be.

You ask if they need help with something and you get The Look. The sigh. The “I’m FINE, Mom.” The door closing a little harder than it needs to.

And it stings — because six months ago they would have wanted you there.

I’ve been on the other side of that closed door. I know the hollow feeling. And I know the urge to push your way back in — to fix it, to reconnect, to remind them you’re still their person.

Don’t. That urge is about your needs, not theirs. And it will make them push harder.

Here’s what actually works. Wait for a calm moment — not in the heat of it — and open with curiosity instead of correction.

Hey, the other day when I asked you to clean your room you seemed really frustrated about me helping. What was going on there?

Then stop talking. Let them answer. You might hear something that surprises you.

When one of my girls pushed back on room cleaning, I asked her what she thought a clean room should look like. Her standard was higher than mine. She didn’t need my expectations — she needed me to get out of the way and let her own it.

That’s the shift. You’re not pulling them closer. You’re saying: I see you growing up, and I trust you enough to give you some space. Show me what you can do with it.

Try this week: Pick the thing they’re pushing back on hardest. When it’s calm, ask them what they think the standard should be — and just listen.

Connection is about how they relate to you. But there’s something else shaping who they’re becoming when you’re not in the room.

Character

Your kids aren’t listening to your lectures on honesty. They’re watching what you do when you get the wrong change at the grocery store.

They see you snap at the slow driver. They see you keep scrolling when you said you’d put your phone down. They see you follow through — or not.

Character is caught before it’s taught. And if you’re teaching it through devotionals and dinner-table lectures without living it in front of them, they’ll notice the gap. Kids always do.

So get intentional. If you could only choose 5 character qualities to raise your kids with — which ones?

Mine were: Kindness. Ownership. Initiative. Responsibility. Resilience.

The trick isn’t the list. It’s using the actual words — out loud, on purpose, until they become family language.

In our house, Initiative was the big one. I’d say, “Hey, could you take initiative and notice the table needs wiping — and wipe it.” They’d do it, and I’d say, tongue in cheek, “Thanks for taking initiative. I appreciate it.”

It started deliberate. Then it became a running joke — “Hey, I’m taking initiative!” They’d say it with a grin, half mocking me, half meaning it.

And years later, when one of my daughters’ boss pulled her aside to say he’d noticed her initiative — she called to tell me. That one landed.

Naming matters. It gives them a vocabulary for the kind of person they’re becoming. And eventually, they start to own it without you saying a word.

Try this week: Write down your top 5 character qualities. Stick them on the fridge. When you see one — name it out loud.

Connection is how they relate to you. Character is who they’re becoming. Now for the one most of us default to worrying about first.

Competence

The fastest way to help your kid learn something? Stop pushing them to get it right.

You know the cycle. They sit down to math. They get stuck on the same kind of problem they got stuck on yesterday. You explain it again. They nod. They try. They get it wrong. Someone cries. Maybe both of you. And tomorrow you’ll do it all over again.

I know this cycle because I’ve lived it — at the kitchen table with my kids and at the piano with my own practice. When I’m learning a new piece and I play straight through, hoping the rough spots will magically smooth out — they don’t. They just get more grooved in.

But when I stop at the two bars where my fingers fall apart, slow way down, work through what’s actually tripping me up, and then build back to tempo — I improve faster. It feels like the slow way. It’s not.

Your kid’s schoolwork is the same. Somewhere underneath the daily frustration is a specific point where the understanding broke down. Maybe the long division struggle is actually a multiplication facts problem. Maybe the writing resistance is actually a “can’t organize my thoughts” problem.

The beauty of homeschooling is you can stop. You can back up to where it fell apart and work that one thing — without a classroom of 30 kids setting the pace.

Try this week: Find the subject that’s causing the most tears. Don’t push through it again. Back up. Find where the understanding actually broke. Work that spot.

That’s your 3 Cs for the week. You don’t have to tackle all three — just the one that stuck with you. Even a small step counts.

Hit reply and tell me — which C are you working on this week?